| 1969 | Eric Florence | All - Ohio (Baseball) | ||
| 1971 | Bo Bradley | All - American (Football) | ||
| 1973 | Boys Basketball | FAVC Champions | ||
| 1974 | Boys Basketball | FAVC Champions | ||
| 1975 | Boys Basketball | FAVC Champions | ||
| 1980 | Kenton Trace Conference Champions (Football, Cross Country, Tennis) | |||
| Rusty Kuriger | 1st Team All-State, SW District - Lineman of the Year (Football) | |||
| Greg Patterson | 3rd Team All-State (Football) | |||
| Darrell Wahsum | Honorable Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Duwayne Raines | Special Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| 1981 | Kenton Trace Conference Champions and District Champions (Girls' Basketball) | |||
| Kenton Trace Conference Champions (Football, Tennis) | ||||
| Associated Press State Champions (Football) | ||||
| David Deters | 1st Team All-State (Football) | |||
| Chris Chenoweth | 3rd Team All-State (Football) | |||
| Kirk Kennedy | Honorable Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Doug Perdue |
2nd Team All-State (Football) State Qualifier (Discus) |
|||
| Russell Winsted | 2nd Team All-State (Football) | |||
| Keith Mescher | Associated Press Coach of the Year (Football) | |||
| Pam Scherer | 3rd Team All-State and District 15 Player of the Year (Girls Basketball) | |||
| Mary Williams | Honorable Mention All-State (Girls Basketball) | |||
| 1983 | Kenton Trace Conference Champions (Tennis) | |||
| 1984 | Kenton Trace Conference Champions (Tennis) | |||
| Chris Brower | State Qualifier (Tennis) | |||
| Mike Cassidy | Special Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Rodney Bailey | Special Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| 1985 | Kenton Trace Conference Champions (Football, Volleyball, Tennis) | |||
| Vance Vair | State Qualifier (400 Meter Dash) | |||
| Lora Whitestine | 3rd in State (300 Meter Hurdles) | |||
| Jamie George |
3rd in State (100 Meter Hurdles) 2nd in State (Long Jump) |
|||
| 1986 | Kenton Trace Conference Champions (Tennis, Volleyball) | |||
| Lora Whitestine | 3rd in State (100 and 300 Meter Hurdles) | |||
| Jamie George | 5th in State (100 Meter Hurdles) | |||
| Mike Tidwell | State Qualifier (Golf) | |||
| Andy Morgan | Honorable Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Darren Amburgy | Honorable Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Scot Stiles | Honorable Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Steve Taylor | Honorable Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Robert Manning | Honorable Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Tim Williams | 2nd Team All-State (Football) | |||
| Michele Ames | Honorable Mention All-State (Girlsʼ Basketball) | |||
| Mark Anderson | State Qualifier (Golf) | |||
| 1987 | Steve Taylor | Honorable Mention All-State Football | ||
| Tim Williams | 3rd Team All-State (Football) | |||
| Kenton Trace Conference Champions (Football) | ||||
| 1988 | Tim Williams | 2nd Team All-State (Football) | ||
| Jeff Harner | 2nd Team All-State (Football) | |||
| Mike Litherland | State Qualifier (Swimming) | |||
| Marty Hubbell | State Qualifier (Swimming) | |||
| Lee Litherland | State Qualifier (Swimming) | |||
| Jason Praeter | State Qualifier (Swimming) | |||
| Kenton Trace Conference Champions (Baseball, Girlsʼ Cross Country, Football) |
||||
| 1989 | Rob Kallage | 2nd Team All-State (Football) | ||
| Rex Kuriger | 2nd Team All-State (Football) | |||
| Perry Stiles | Honorable Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Kenton Trace Conference Champions (Golf, Baseball) | ||||
| 1990 | Rob Kallage | 1st Team All-State (Baseball) | ||
| Lee Litherland | State Qualifier (Relay Team Swimming) | |||
| Sandra Hartsock | State Qualifier (Relay Team Swimming) | |||
| Marty Hubbell | 3rd in State (200 Individual Medley/100 Meter Breaststroke) | |||
| State Qualifier (Relay Team Swimming) | ||||
| Jason Praeter | 7th in State 50 Freestyle/8th in 100 Butterfly (Swimming) | |||
| State Qualifier (Relay Team Swimming) | ||||
| Tom Boggs | Special Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| April Drake | 8th in State (Grilsʼ Golf) | |||
| 1991 | Jamie Servis | Honorable Mention All-State (Basketball) | ||
| Marty Hubbell | State Champion - 200 Individual Medley/100 Breaststroke; 8th in State 200 Freestyle Relay/11th in 200 Medley Relay | |||
| Jason Praeter | State Champion - 50 Freestyle and 100 Butterfly 8th in State 200 Freestyle Relay 11th in 200 Medley Relay | |||
| Lee Litherland | 6th in State in 200 Individual Medley, 8th in State in 200 Freestyle and 11th in State in 200 Medley Relays | |||
| Sandra Hartsock | 8th i State in 200 Freestyle and 11th in 200 Medley Relays |
|||
| Jennifer Hartsock | 8th in State in 100 Butterfly (Swimming) | |||
| Kris Robinson | State Qualifier (Discus) | |||
| April Drake | 4th in State and Regional Champion Girlsʼ Golf |
|||
| Shane Miller | Honorable Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Kenton Trace Confrence Champions (Girlʼs Track, Golf) | ||||
| Cheerleaders | 4th in Cheerleaders of America Competition in Florida | |||
| 1992 | Marty Hubbell | State Champion - 200 Individual Medley/100 Breaststroke | ||
| Lee Litherland | 5th in State in 200 Individual Medley/12th in 100 Butterfly | |||
| Jennifer Hartsock | 5th in State in 100 Butterfly | |||
| Jill Hartsock | 14th in State in 100 Butterfly/16th in 200 Individual Medley | |||
| Kris Robinson | Regional Champion (Discus), State Qualifier (Discus) | |||
| Mike Hatfield | 1st Team All-State (Football) | |||
| Larry Cornett | Special Mention All-State (Football) | |||
| Volleyball | District Runners-up Division III | |||
| 1993 | Craig Morgan | 7th in State (High Jump) | ||
| Jennifer Hartsock | 5th in State 100 Butterfly | |||
| Volleyball | District Runners-up Division III | |||
| 1994 | Craig Morgan | 9th in State (High Jump) | ||
| Jennifer Hartsock | State Qualifier 100 Butterfly | |||
| Volleyball | District Runners-up Division III | |||
| 1995 | Jill Hartsock | State Qualifier 100 Butterly | ||
| Niki Hice | 3rd Team All-State (Football) | |||
| Tora Coffman | 3rd Team All-State (Girlsʼ Soccer) | |||
| Shannon Smith | State Qualifier (Girlsʼ Golf) | |||
| 1996 | Beth Sells | 3rd Team All-State (Girlsʼ Basketball) | ||
| Niki Hice |
3rd in State, 100 Meters (Track) 6th in State, 200 Meters (Track) |
|||
| Niki Hice, Jeremy Gallagher, Justin Trentham, Matt Phillips |
2nd in State 400 Relay | |||
| Jessica Warren | State Qualifier Girlsʼ Long Jump (Track) | |||
| Baseball District Champions, Regional Qualifiers | ||||
| Tora Coffman | 1st Team All-State (Girlsʼ Soccer), District Player of the Year | |||
| D. J. Collins | State Qualifier (Wrestling) | |||
| 1997 | Rick Kincaid | State Qualifier (Wrestling) | ||
| D. J. Collins | State Qualifier (Wrestling) | |||
| Beth Sells | Special Mention All-State (Basketball) | |||
| Baseball KTC Champs, District Runners-Up | ||||
| Girls Basketball | District Runner-Up | |||
| Shannon Smith | District Medalist, Regional Runner-Up, 9th at State, All State Second Team (Golf) | |||
| Girls Soccer | KTC Champions, District Runner-up | |||
| 1998 | Jessica Hupe | Honorable Mention- All State- Girls Basketball | ||
| Rick Kincaid | District Champion- 11th State Wrestling | |||
| Jessica Warren | Regional Champion Long Jump, State Qualifier | |||
| Tom Swartzel | 2nd Team All State- Football | |||
| Joe Bradley | Special Mention- All State Football | |||
| Jessica Hupe | All-State Soccer- 3rd Team | |||
| Girls & Boys Soccer | KTC Champs | |||
| Girls Soccer | District Runner-Up | |||
| 1999 | Jessica Hupe | All-State Special Mention (Girls Basketball) | ||
| KTC Champs | Baseball, Girls Soccer | |||
| Girls Basketball, Softball | District Runner-Up | |||
| KTC All-Sports Champs | ||||
| Jessica Hupe | 2nd Team All-State (Girls Soccer) | |||
| Joe Bradley | 2nd Team All-State (Football) | |||
| B.J. Truesdale | 2nd Team All-State (Football) | |||
| 2000 | Matthew Letts | 3rd Team All-State Soccer | ||
| Jessica Hupe | ||||
| Jennifer Kapper | ||||
| Nick Garret | ||||
| KTC Champs | Football, Girls Tennis, Girls Soccer, Girls Cross Country, Volleyball | |||
| District Runner-Up | Girls Soccer, Volleyball | |||
| KTC All-Sports Champs | ||||
| Ben Griggs | Regional Champion, State (6th) Long Jump | |||
| Aaron Dimbath, Jon Stubbs, Paul Phillips, Ben Griggs | State Qualifier 400 Relay | |||
| 2001 | District Champs | Boys Basketball, Boys Soccer | ||
| District Champion | Molly Allen- Girls Shot-Put, Ben Griggs- Long Jump | |||
| State Qualifiers | Molly Allen- Shot & Discus, Ben Griggs, Aaron Dimbath, Jon Stubbs, Paul Phillips | |||
| Matt Letts | 2nd Team All-State- Boys Soccer | |||
| SWBL-Buckey Division Champs | Boys Soccer, Girls Soccer, Golf, Volleyball | |||
| 2002 | Kelly Currin | District Player of the Year- Girls Basketball | ||
| Mimi Goodyear | All-State 3rd Team-Girls Basketball | |||
| Softball | District Champs, Regional Runner-Up | |||
| Girls Basketball | District Runner-Up, 3rd in State (AP) | |||
| Boys Basketball | AP State Champions Division III | |||
| SWBL All-Sports Champs | Buckeye-Division | |||
| Kellen Shank | 2nd Team All-State- Basketball | |||
| Tim Gabbard | Girls Basketball- State Coach of the Year | |||
| Jim Philpot | Boys Basketball- State Coach of the Year | |||
| Ashley Fosnaugh | 2nd Team All-State- Girls Soccer | |||
| Daniel Liles | 3rd Team All-State- Boys Soccer | |||
| Girls Soccer | League, District, Regional Champs, State Final Four | |||
| SWBL League Champs | Golf, Girls Soccer, Boys Soccer | |||
| Terry Monroe | State Qualifier- Wrestling | |||
| Carter Shaver | State Qualifier- Wrestling | |||
| Nick Steiner | State Qualifier- Wrestling | |||
| Chas Franz | State Qualifier- Wrestling | |||
| Jon Stubbs | State Qualifier- Long Jump | |||
| 2003 | SWBL League Champs | Boys Basketball, Girls Basketball, Softball | ||
| Chas Franz | State Wrestling-3rd | |||
| Terry Monroe | State Wrestling- 6th | |||
| Mimi Goodyear | State Wrestling- 8th | |||
| Kristen Raab | State Qualifier Swimming-100 Backstroke & 100 Butterfly | |||
| Kellen Shank | 2nd Team All-State Basketball | |||
| SWBL All Sports Champs | ||||
| Mollie Stock | All-State 1st Team Sofbtall | |||
| 2004 | SWBL Champs | Boys & Girls Tennis, Boys & Girls Basketball, Softball | ||
| Softball | Regional Runner-Ups | |||
| SWBL All Sports Champs | ||||
| Chas Franz | State Qualifier- Wrestling | |||
| Nick Steiner | State Qualifier- Wrestling | |||
| Aleshia Bors | Honorable Mention All-State Girls Basketball | |||
| Candice Raab | State Qualifier- Swimming | |||
| Mollie Stock | First Team All-State Softball | |||
| 2005 | SWBL Champs | Girls Tennis, Golf, Girls Soccer, Volleyball, Boys & Girls Basketball, Softball | ||
| Jessica Ewing | 2nd Team All-State Girls Soccer | |||
| Stephanie & Tammi Isaacs | 8th State Tennis (Doubles Division II) | |||
| Elyse Velte | 8th State Cross Country (Division II), 6th State 1600 M Run | |||
| Aleshia Bors | 2nd Team All-State Basketball Division III | |||
| Nick Steiner | 6th State Wrestling Team | |||
| Candice Raab | 16th State Swimming 500 Freestyle | |||
| Girls Basketball | District & Regional Champs, State Final Four | |||
| Mollie Stock | First Team All-State Softball | |||
| Elizabeth Shank | 2nd Team All-State Softball | |||
| Abigail Nelson | First Team Basketball, State Final Four | |||
| 2006 | SWBL Champs | Girls & Boys Tennis, Boys Golf, Volleyball, Football, Girls Soccer, Boys & Girls Basketball | ||
| Stephanie & Tammi Isaacs | State Qualifier Tennis Doubles | |||
| Candice Raab | 18th- 200 Freestyle, 16th 500 Freestyle, Swimming | |||
| Liz Shank | All-State Honorable Mention Basketball, 1st Team Al-State Softball | |||
| Elyse Velte | 12th State 1600 Meter Run | |||
| Ben Roeser | State Qualifier Boys Tennis | |||
| Mike Powell | 2nd Team All State-Football | |||
| 2007 | Boys Golf | SWBL Champs | ||
| Joe Lamb | 2nd Team All-State Football Division V | |||
| Mike Powell | Special Mention All-State Football Division V | |||
| Molly Fitzpatrick | 3rd Team All-State Girls Soccer | |||
| Ben Roeser & Dylan Schwerdferger | State Qualifier Division II Doubles-Tennis | |||
| 2008 | SWBL Champs | Boys & Girls Tennis, Boys Golf | ||
| SWBL All-Sports Champs | ||||
| Dustin Hogan | 1st Team All-State Div V, Defensive Lineman of the Year Southwest District | |||
| Brady Deters | 2nd Team All-State Div V Defensive Back | |||
| Matt McKeever | 2nd Team All-State Div V Offensive Lineman | |||
| McKenna Warfel | State Qualifier Swimming (500 Free & 100 Back) | |||
| Alyssa Ritchie | State Qualifier Girls Tennis | |||
| Ben Roeser | State Qualifier Boys Tennis | |||
| 2009 | SWBL Champs | Football, Girls Tennis, Boys Cross Country, Boys Golf, Boys & Girls Basketball | ||
| Girls Soccer | District Champs | |||
| SWBL All Sports Champs | ||||
| Brady Deters | All-State Div V First Team- Defensive Back | |||
| Seth Millar | All-State Div V First Team- Offensive Back, Offensive Back of the Year Southwest District | |||
| Lucas Hammonds | Special Mentions Div V- Offensive Line | |||
| Joe Hernandez | Special Mention All-State Div V- Linebacker | |||
| Lauren Price | 2nd Team All-State Soccer | |||
| Glen Burchfield | Southwest District Coach of the Year- Football | |||
| Jacob Kramb | 12th State 100 Backstroke | |||
| Cody Steiner | State Qualifier Wrestling | |||
| Jessica Dahnke | 11th in State Div II Discus- Track | |||
| 800 M Relay Team | 7th in State Div III Track- Kyle Keegan, Jeff Messinger, Seth Millar, Tyler Johnson | |||
| Samantha VanAtta | All-Ohio Honorable Mention Div III | |||
| Travis Williams | All-Ohio Special Mention Div III | |||
| 2010 | Alyssa Ritchie | State Singles Champion Tennis Div II- Undefeated | ||
| SWBL Champs | Boys & Girls Tennis, Girls Soccer, Boys Golf, Football | |||
| Lauren Price | 2nd Team All-State Soccer Div III | |||
| Seth Millar | 2nd Team All-State Football Div IV | |||
| Caleb Keeton | Special Mention Football Div IV | |||
| Cody Steiner | 4th State Wrestling Div III 103 lb. | |||
| Jessica Dahnke | 9th State Discus Div II | |||
| Kevin Cornett | 14th State Discus II | |||
| 2011 | Alyssa Ritche | State Singles Champion Tennis Div II- Undefeated | ||
| SWBL Champs | Boys Golf, Boys & Girls Soccer | |||
| Caleb Keeton | All-State 2nd Team Football Div IV-Kicker | |||
| Taylor Petersen | 19th State Swimming 500 Freestyle | |||
| Cody Steiner | 2nd State Div III Wrestling 119 lbs | |||
| 2012 | SWBL Champs | Football, Boys Soccer, Girls Cross Country | ||
| Luke Creditt | 1st Team All-Ohio Football- Div IV | |||
| Isaac Hammonds | 2nd Team All-Ohio- Div IV | |||
| Caleb Keeton | 2nd Team All-Ohio Football Div IV | |||
| Hunter Schmidt | Special Mention All-Ohio Football Div IV | |||
| 2013 | Brian Behymer | Special Mention, All-State Football, Div V | ||
| Marissa Caldwell | 2nd Team, All-State Soccer | |||
| 2014 | Chase Struewing | 3rd Team All-State Football | ||
| Dillon Sarka | Special Mention, All-State Football, Div V | |||
| Carly Allen | 1st Team, All-State Softball | |||
| Troy Black | 2nd Team, All-State Baseball | |||
| 2015 | Brooke Lezotte | 1st Team All-State Soccer | ||
| Carly Allen | 2nd Team, All-State Softball | |||
| Troy Black | 1st Team, All-State Baseball | |||
| Jeremiah Stillwell | 1st Team, All-State Baseball | |||
| Christian Zidaroff | State Track Qualifier, 1600 Meter Relay Team | |||
| Zach Van Dyke | State Track Qualifer, 1600 Meter Relay Team | |||
| Trevor Johnson | State Track Qualifer, 1600 Meter Relay Team | |||
| Ramsey Skeens | State Track Qualifer, 1600 Meter Relay Team | |||
| 2016 | Chase Struewing | 1st Team All-State Football | ||
| Tayler Steele | State Qualifier- Wrestling | |||
| Sabrina Ball | State Qualifier- 200 Medley Relay | |||
| Tara Nix | State Qualifier- 200 Medley Relay | |||
| Kylee Meredith | State Qualifier- 200 Medley Relay | |||
| Kierstyn Cassidy | State Qualifier- 200 Medley Relay | |||
| Brooke Lezotte | 1st Team All-State Soccer | |||
| Rachel Murray | Honorable Mention All-State Basketball | |||